Full text: letter written to protest against Wharton's invite to Modi
Here is the full text of the letter drafted by three University of Pennsylvania professors - Ania Loomba, Catherine Bryson Professor of English; Suvir Kaul, A M Rosenthal Professor of English and Toorjo Ghose, Assistant Professor at the School of Social Policy and Practice - and signed by hundreds of eminent academics and members of the intelligentsia to protest against Wharton's India Economic Forum's invite to Narendra Modi to deliver the keynote address on March 23. This petition led to cancellation of the invite.
We (professors, students, lawyers, writers, doctors, and concerned citizens from
Philadelphia and around the world) are outraged to learn
that the Wharton India Economic Forum has invited Narendra Modi, the Chief
Minister of the Indian state of Gujarat, to be
a keynote speaker at its 17th Economic Forum on March 23, 2013.
Since then, the Supreme Court of India has repeatedly faulted the
government led by Mr Modi for failing to prosecute those guilty of the crimes
in 2002 and instead of prosecuting whistle-blowers and activists who had tried
to bring the guilty to justice. In February 2012, the Supreme Court again
criticized the Modi government for using trumped-up charges to harass activists
fighting for justice. What this sordid record proves is Mr Modi's callous
disregard for the life of Indian citizens and for the Indian Constitution.
In taking cognizance of Mr Modi's culpability, the State Department also revoked his "existing tourist/business visa under section 212 (a) (2) (g) of the Immigration and Nationality Act." As David C. Mulford, U.S. Ambassador to
India, explained then, "Section 212 (a) (2)
(g) makes any foreign government official who 'was responsible for or directly
carried out, at any time, particularly severe violations of religious freedom'
ineligible for a visa to the ." Ambassador Mulford went on to
say that the State Department's decision was "based on the fact that, as
head of the State government in United
between February 2002 and May 2002, [Modi] was responsible for the performance
of state institutions at that time." The State Department's detailed views
on this matter are included in its annual Country Reports on Human Rights
Practices and the International Religious Freedom Report. Both reports document
the violence in Gujarat from February 2002 to
May 2002 and cite the Indian National Human Rights Commission report, which
states there was "a comprehensive failure on the part of the state
government to control the persistent violation of rights of life, liberty,
equality, and dignity of the people of the state." (http://2001-2009.state.gov/p/sca/rls/rm/2005/43701.htm).
It is incomprehensible to us that this is the man who the Wharton India Economic Forum wishes to celebrate as an exemplar of economic and social development. We find it astonishing that any academic and student body at the University of Pennsylvania can endorse ideas about economic development that are based on the systematic oppression of minority populations, whether in India or elsewhere. Our role as scholars and students-and indeed as would-be entrepreneurs and business managers-must be to develop conscientious and efficacious modes of economic organization, not to piggy-back onto the inhuman policies of politicians who not only lack a commitment to human rights and to ideals of social justice, but whose political success is based on the suppression of substantial sections of their own citizens. Mr Modi still does not have a
US visa to enter the , but Wharton plans to present
him on Skype to the audience. Recently there have been efforts to whitewash
Modi's grim record and to grant him international respectability. Wharton's
invitation lends itself to doing just that. US
We urge the Wharton India Economic Forum to revoke their invitation to Narendra Modi. If it does not do not do so, we pledge to protest his presence-virtual as it will be, given that he remains ineligible for a US visa-in a variety of ways, including at the meeting of the Forum. We will also do all that we can to continue to educate our community about the incalculable and continuing harm done by Modi's brand of politics to the secular values enshrined in India's Constitution.
(We should add that signatures are pouring in, and the following names represent those who signed within a few hours of the circulation of this letter.)
End of Letter