tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post8878693634189915112..comments2024-03-28T14:52:32.155-07:00Comments on Human Rights India: SAHMAT's Statement on Ayodhya VerdictUnknownnoreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post-49396161776599535872010-10-04T01:16:07.259-07:002010-10-04T01:16:07.259-07:00atleast Sahhmat could speak out the truth, thanks....atleast Sahhmat could speak out the truth, thanks..after the judgement the only thing that mattered to the media as well as intellectuals seemed that India should move on etc etc.. but the cosr of that moving forward was never thought of.. the judgement seemed to be the biggest roadblock not only to the secular fabric but also to the ethos of all encompassing Indian civilization...the courts cannot judge matters of belief and so when it pinpoints the place where Ram was born it makes a mockery of justice.. alongwith Babri demolotion the entire case was nothing but the barbicue of what post-colonial India stood forgorky chakrabortynoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post-22586941405043017572010-10-02T13:30:32.460-07:002010-10-02T13:30:32.460-07:00At first glance the Court's decision to trifur...At first glance the Court's decision to trifurcate this piece of land may seem to be the best suited in the circumstances. But looking at it rationally, the judgment seems to misconstrued & flawed. It is more a political settlement to the dispute.<br /><br />Though the case involved religious issues that are deeply inimical to public interest, the court should have avoided giving legal force to a subjective or perceived opinion or in this case belief. The judiciary should have purely limited itself to remain within the legal framework.<br /><br />The precepts of any one community cannot, by force of their being in a religious majority, sound any louder in the general law than the precepts of any other.<br /><br />The courts sought to uphold and defend the perceived beliefs that this particular piece of land was the birth place of Ram. This would mean laws being imposed not to advance the general good on objective grounds, but to give effect to the force of subjective opinion.<br /><br />Unfortunately, this decision by the Allahbad High Court would open up the pandora's box & be a judicial precedent & legal doctrine for all such claims on other religious sites in the future.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post-21496539743639390612010-10-02T12:22:30.403-07:002010-10-02T12:22:30.403-07:00The best place on earth for communists is China. Y...The best place on earth for communists is China. You will love that country. You communists are the biggest abusers of democracy.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post-32209853856169117442010-10-02T10:27:38.334-07:002010-10-02T10:27:38.334-07:00This is more of a loser's statement. If the ju...This is more of a loser's statement. If the judiciary goes against your claim they are bad otherwise they are great. It appears more like sushma swaraj saying she would trounce her head if Sonia Gandhi becomes prime minister. Just show some dignity when you lose either a court battle or elections in a democracy.These so called "eminent historians" (please read as CPM's pracharaks) can collect all the bones and "surkhi" to supreme court to prove their point.<br /> On a lighter note: Russian people got upset with Lenin within 50 years that they couldn't even stand his statue firget about his ideology. Somehow 10 avatars of Vishnu remained for the last 2000 years even by your own distorted history.Srinivasa Raonoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-15608335.post-80637720998889237802010-10-01T09:36:47.669-07:002010-10-01T09:36:47.669-07:00itzzz a big shame for our country..... being a stu...itzzz a big shame for our country..... being a student of history and a citizen of a so called secular country it is really hard for me to accept the verdict , which is based on some mythology and belief of a particular religion rather the historical and archaeological evidences taking into account ......<br /><br />salute to these eminent people in the field of history for their concern .......sagnik banerjeenoreply@blogger.com